IDS 2027 16–20 March · CologneHall 11.3 · Aisle A · Booth 085Hall 11.3 · Booth A085 Book a meeting at our boothBook a meeting

Zirconia Bridges: Why Material Data Alone Don’t Predict Fracture Load

Quick Answer

Material strength values alone do not tell you how a multi-unit zirconia bridge will perform. In a new study published in the Journal of Functional Biomaterials, researchers from Charité Berlin, LMU Munich and SimQ tested five-unit monolithic bridges made from 3Y, 4Y and 5Y zirconia. Disc strength differed strongly between the materials, bridge fracture loads differed much less, and every bridge broke at the connector. A finite element analysis (FEA) had identified exactly this connector as the point of highest tensile stress.

Five-unit monolithic zirconia bridge on a 3D-printed abutment carrier and in the fracture test
(a) Five-unit zirconia bridge cemented on a 3D-printed abutment carrier; (b) fracture test with a steel sphere at tooth 35. Source: Schwab et al., J. Funct. Biomater. 2026, 17(10), 529, CC BY 4.0.

The study at a glance

  • Publication: “Biaxial Flexural Strength and Fracture Behavior of Five-Unit Monolithic Zirconia Fixed Dental Prostheses: An Experimental and Finite Element Study”, Journal of Functional Biomaterials, 2026, 17(10), 529
  • Authors: Theresa Schwab (LMU Munich), Jamila Yassine, Robert Nicic (Charité Berlin), Felix Borges, Alexander Pugachev (SimQ) and Franziska Schmidt (Charité Berlin)
  • Materials: 3Y-TZP, 4Y-PSZ and 5Y-PSZ zirconia
  • Specimens: 45 discs for biaxial flexural strength according to DIN EN ISO 6872:2015 and 24 five-unit bridges (teeth 33 to 37) with deliberately undersized connectors
  • Method: fracture tests combined with a finite element analysis of the complete test setup in Ansys

Result 1: Disc strength does not translate one to one into bridge strength

The standardized disc tests showed large, statistically significant differences between all three materials. In the bridges, these differences shrank considerably.

MaterialBiaxial flexural strength (discs)Fracture load (five-unit bridges)
3Y-TZP1406.5 ± 133.3 MPa542.1 ± 44.9 N
4Y-PSZ1146.9 ± 215.9 MPa466.6 ± 116.6 N
5Y-PSZ657.0 ± 137.5 MPa372.1 ± 32.1 N
Mean values ± standard deviation from the study.

5Y-PSZ reached less than half the disc strength of 3Y-TZP (about 53 % lower), but its bridges failed at a load only about 31 % lower. Only 5Y-PSZ showed significantly lower bridge fracture loads than 3Y-TZP. The bridge results for 4Y-PSZ did not differ significantly from either 3Y-TZP or 5Y-PSZ.

Result 2: All bridges failed at the connector the FE model flagged

Every bridge initially fractured at the undersized connector. This is exactly the location where the finite element model showed the highest tensile stress. The simulation reproduced the test setup in full: test pot, embedding, abutment carrier, abutments, bridge and loading sphere.

Finite element model of the five-unit zirconia bridge test setup in Ansys
(a) Complete Ansys model of the test setup; (b) meshing of bridge and abutments. Source: Schwab et al., J. Funct. Biomater. 2026, 17(10), 529, CC BY 4.0.
FE stress distribution in a five-unit zirconia bridge with peak stress at the connector
Simulated stress distribution in a 3Y-TZP bridge at fracture load. The stress peak sits at the connector where the bridges broke in the test. Source: Schwab et al., J. Funct. Biomater. 2026, 17(10), 529, CC BY 4.0.

What this means for dental labs and designers

  • Connector geometry is decisive. With an undersized connector, the connector dominates the failure behavior, and the material grade plays a smaller role than strength tables suggest. How to check connectors and other production rules automatically before milling is covered in dental STL quality control software: 7 criteria.
  • Material data sheets are not enough. A high flexural strength value does not guarantee a robust bridge, and a lower value does not automatically mean the bridge will fail.
  • Simulation finds the weak spot before production. FEA showed where the bridge would break before it was tested. This is the approach behind SimQ DENTAL Simulation: check the stress distribution of a specific design before it is milled.

Limits of the study

The bridges were designed with deliberately undersized connectors to provoke a defined failure. The results therefore describe this setup and cannot be transferred directly to every clinical case. The FE analysis correctly identified the fracture-critical connector. It was not used to predict the absolute fracture load, because the simulations were calibrated to the measured fracture loads.

FAQ

Is 5Y zirconia too weak for five-unit bridges?

The study does not answer that in general. 5Y-PSZ bridges failed at significantly lower loads than 3Y-TZP bridges, but the gap was much smaller than the disc strength values suggest. With undersized connectors, the connector design had a decisive influence.

Can FEA predict where a dental bridge will break?

In this study, yes: all bridges initially failed at the connector where the FE model showed the highest tensile stress. The absolute fracture load was not predicted, as the model was calibrated to the experiments.

Where can I read the full paper?

The article is open access: doi.org/10.3390/jfb17100529.

Check your own designs: see where your restorations carry the highest stress before they are milled: discover SimQ DENTAL Simulation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *